The 6 Most Haunted Places Near New York City

The next time you’re in New York, how about experiencing a spine-tingling thrill? Given the fascinating and rich history of New York City, there are a lot of unexplained phenomena there as well. Everyone who believes in or is interested in the paranormal can find something to interest them, from ghost tours through graveyards to haunted hotels.

Washington Square Park

Situated in Greenwich Village, Manhattan, Washington Square Park is a picturesque urban green space ideal for leisurely strolls and picnics. However, when this 9.75-acre park was constructed over a cemetery, the municipal planners gained a little more than they bargained for. It was a public cemetery at the period of the American Revolution. For unidentified corpses, unidentified tourists, or those unable to afford burial in other, more reputable places, it offered a last resting place. Early in the 1800s, it closed. There were perhaps 20,000 persons buried there at that point.

Although the tree’s identity is unknown in the surviving records, other accounts indicate it being used for hangings in the park. Unofficial lore claims that the notorious “Hangman’s Elm” or “Hanging Tree” is an elm located in the northwest corner of the park. Whether or not real executions happened right away is unknown. Even if it isn’t the oldest tree in the city, the Hangman’s Elm is more than 300 years old.

The site had previously been a cemetery, as excavations conducted in the 1890s revealed when the park was planned and the famous archway was built. When construction got underway, tombstones and corpses were discovered. Even when tales of unearthly occurrences in the area persisted, construction went ahead. Currently, park visitors describe feeling chilly patches or having the impression that someone is around, particularly at night. Washington Square Park is an excellent place to come if you’re hoping to have a paranormal experience because of its legends around hauntings.

Machpelah Cemetery

It should come as no surprise that there are many strange happenings at Queens’ Machpelah Cemetery, the final resting place of magician Harry Houdini. There, Houdini is interred with his mother, father, five brothers, sister, and grandfather. Although no one has been able to locate one, there are persistent rumors that there is a hidden chamber in the cemetery or in Houdini’s grave.

Despite this, contemporary magicians and fans of Harry Houdini continue to come to the location to pay their respects. Large parties were thrown by the Society of American Magicians to honor Houdini, who passed away on the eerie date of October 31st. A bust in his likeness was also erected by the organization. Vandalism at the graveyard in more recent years has prompted other groups and individuals to take up the cause. The cemetery seems abandoned in certain areas and has an overall eerie, dilapidated atmosphere.

The Algonquin Hotel

Go to the Algonquin Hotel if you want to shake hands with a ghost. In the 1920s, renowned writers and other creative types convened in the hotel’s dining room to exchange concepts and exchange works. Following a meeting at the Algonquin, Harold Ross and his wife Jane Grant even went on to create The New Yorker in 1925. The unsettling aspect is that a few of these imaginative wizards might have never left the hotel. Both guests and employees claim to have heard singing in the elevators, footsteps in the hallways, and even shushing that is said to be the voice of the late poet Dorothy Parker, a frequent guest of the hotel.

Like the spirits did all those years ago, you can visit one of the dining rooms or lounges or stay in the hotel. Maybe as otherworldly spirits, they prefer to stay in their old haunts and continue to indulge their creative instincts. Ghost hunters are investigating the hotel in response to reports of spirits in order to produce a television special.

The House of Death

Can this old brownstone in Greenwich Village, with a name like that, be anything else than haunted? The eerie history of the house dates back to a string of unfortunate events that occurred in the late 1800s, including rodents moving objects around the house, a cyclist striking and hurting a small child, and other unsettling things.

After his literary career came to an end, author Mark Twain spent about a year living in the house. Despite being a well-known writer, he experienced financial hardship and sadness while he was residing there. That’s why it comes as a little surprise that guests still claim to have seen his ghost there. Twain’s ghost roams the house, despite the fact that he was living somewhere else when he passed away. Additionally, many claim to have heard someone marching on the higher levels or going up and down the stairs. Maybe even after he passed away, he returned to the scene because of his difficult times spent there.

In the 1950s, Jan Bryant Bartell, another writer, resided in one of the flats on the top levels. She felt there were ghosts in the house because she had feelings of wetness and chill. She was particularly interested in paranormal activities. In the house, there were odd odors as well as disturbed animal behavior. Experts in paranormal matters that Bartell brought in asserted that The House of Death was home to up to 22 ghosts. About her experiences living in this haunted house, she went on to write a book.

New Amsterdam Theatre

The New Amsterdam Theatre has been the mainstay of the Broadway experience since it first opened its doors in 1903. It is Broadway’s oldest theater. Many people think the interior is among the most exquisite in the entire city. With its peculiar Art Nouveau flair, the design is very beautiful.

The New Amsterdam features a resident ghost, just like the majority of theaters in New York City. Olive Thomas performed brilliantly as a chorus girl in The Ziegfeld Follies. The 14-year run of this play in the early 1900s distinguished New Amsterdam from the burgeoning New York theater scene of the day. The chorus girls in particular gave lavish, extravagantly glamorous performances. Olive abruptly passed away from mercury poisoning in 1920. There were theories regarding her unexpected demise, such as accidental deaths, suicides, or even murders. Nonetheless, her spirit is usually amiable, and some claim to have seen her do a lifelike dance for her audience on stage.

Blood Manor

This estate that has been transformed into a haunted home is eerie by design, but there are also a lot of paranormal events in the original tale. The residence, which is in Tribeca, has been in operation for 20 years. Celebrities like Jimmy Fallon and Kevin Hart even graced its stage. The latter, on his visit to the haunted house, cried out for more than four minutes on camera.

However, the house’s eerie past started much earlier, when in the middle of the 19th century, photographer Matthew Brady captured images of well-known personalities at the mansion. The home and studio that created the image of Abraham Lincoln that is on U.S. coinage is also responsible. Brady also took pictures of soldiers on the front lines of the Civil War. Each picture had distorted features or eerie apparitions in it when he went back to the studio to develop it. He reported hearing actual screams coming from the house and characterized them as such. There have also been reports of hearing gunfire and seeing soldiers from the American Civil War loitering within the home. Blood Manor offers a solid scare, whether you’re looking for a haunted house production or the paranormal.